A statement is given below, followed by two arguments, 1 and 2. Decide which of the given arguments is strong and supports the statement.
Statement: Should taxes be abolished in a developing country like India?
Argument 1: No, taxes are a good source of income for the government to take steps for the development of the country.
Argument 2: Yes, these taxes are NOT used for the goodwill of the nation.
- AOnly 1 argument is strong
- BOnly 2 argument is strong
- CBoth argument 1 and 2 are strong
- DNeither arguments 1 nor 2 is strong
Solution & Step-by-step Explanation
* Argument 1 is strong because taxation is a globally established fundamental fiscal tool for any government to collect revenue to build public infrastructure and fund development projects, especially in a developing nation.
* Argument 2 is a generalized negative claim and a weak argument because it focuses on a prescriptive assumption of misuse rather than addressing the structural necessity of taxes for national planning.
* Argument 2 is a generalized negative claim and a weak argument because it focuses on a prescriptive assumption of misuse rather than addressing the structural necessity of taxes for national planning.