Four cards are placed on a table. Each card has a number on one side and a letter on the other. The cards on display show , , and . Which cards must be turned over to satisfy our requirement?
"If a card has a vowel on one side, then it has an even number on the other side."
- Aand
- Band
- Cand
- Dand
Solution & Step-by-step Explanation
This is a classic logic problem (Wason Selection Task). Let's evaluate the conditional rule: **"If Vowel (), then Even Number ()"**.
To test a conditional statement , we must check two cases:
1. The case that confirms (to see if it leads to ).
2. The case that violates (to make sure it doesn't come from , by Modus Tollens).
Let's verify each visible card:
* Card '3' (Odd Number): This is a violation of an even number (). If we turn it over and find a vowel, the rule is violated. Therefore, we must turn over card .
* Card '8' (Even Number): This represents . The rule states "If vowel even", but it does not state that an even number can only have a vowel. An even number can have a consonant on the other side without breaking the rule. So, we do not need to check card .
* Card 'E' (Vowel): This represents . We must check it to confirm that there is an even number on the other side.
* Card 'K' (Consonant): The rule says nothing about consonants. Turning it over tells us nothing useful.
Thus, we must turn over cards ** and **.
To test a conditional statement , we must check two cases:
1. The case that confirms (to see if it leads to ).
2. The case that violates (to make sure it doesn't come from , by Modus Tollens).
Let's verify each visible card:
* Card '3' (Odd Number): This is a violation of an even number (). If we turn it over and find a vowel, the rule is violated. Therefore, we must turn over card .
* Card '8' (Even Number): This represents . The rule states "If vowel even", but it does not state that an even number can only have a vowel. An even number can have a consonant on the other side without breaking the rule. So, we do not need to check card .
* Card 'E' (Vowel): This represents . We must check it to confirm that there is an even number on the other side.
* Card 'K' (Consonant): The rule says nothing about consonants. Turning it over tells us nothing useful.
Thus, we must turn over cards ** and **.