Given below is a statement followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a strong argument.
Statement: Should the private sector be permitted to operate hospitals in India?
Arguments: I. Yes, they are operated in advanced western countries.
II. No, it is risky to put the hospitals in private hands.
- AOnly argument I is strong
- BOnly argument II is strong
- CNeither argument I nor II is strong
- DBoth arguments I and II are strong
Solution & Step-by-step Explanation
Let us analyze both arguments:
* Argument I states that private hospitals should be allowed just because they are operated in advanced western countries. This is a weak argument because a policy cannot be justified for India merely because it exists in another country; socioeconomic conditions differ.
* Argument II states that it is risky to put hospitals in private hands. This is an emotional or generalized claim without a logical explanation as to why it is inherently risky, especially when private health infrastructure coexists effectively in many developing setups.
Therefore, neither argument is strong.
* Argument I states that private hospitals should be allowed just because they are operated in advanced western countries. This is a weak argument because a policy cannot be justified for India merely because it exists in another country; socioeconomic conditions differ.
* Argument II states that it is risky to put hospitals in private hands. This is an emotional or generalized claim without a logical explanation as to why it is inherently risky, especially when private health infrastructure coexists effectively in many developing setups.
Therefore, neither argument is strong.