HomeTestsSearchRankProfile
mediumMCQGATE EC 2014 Question Paper (15-Feb-2014) (Shift 1)General Aptitude
1 mark (−0.33)

Read the statements:

All women are entrepreneurs.

Some women are doctors

Which of the following conclusions can be logically inferred from the above statements?

  1. A
    All women are doctors
  2. B
    All doctors are entrepreneurs
  3. C
    All entrepreneurs are women
  4. D
    Some entrepreneurs are doctors

Solution & Step-by-step Explanation

Analyzing the Syllogism Statements

This question asks us to identify a logical conclusion based on two given statements about women, entrepreneurs, and doctors. We need to carefully examine the relationship between these groups as described in the premises.

Premise 1: All women are entrepreneurs

This statement establishes a universal relationship. It means that the group 'women' is entirely contained within the group 'entrepreneurs'. If someone is a woman, they are definitely an entrepreneur. Using set notation, if W represents the set of all women and E represents the set of all entrepreneurs, this statement can be written as:



In simpler terms, every single member of the 'women' category is also a member of the 'entrepreneurs' category.

Premise 2: Some women are doctors

This statement indicates an overlap between the group 'women' and the group 'doctors'. It means there exists at least one person who is both a woman and a doctor. Using set notation, if D represents the set of all doctors, this statement can be written as:



This tells us that the intersection of the 'women' set and the 'doctors' set is not empty; there's at least one common member.

Evaluating Potential Conclusions

Now, let's examine each of the given options to see which one logically follows from the two premises.

Option 1: All women are doctors

This statement () claims that the entire group of women is contained within the group of doctors. Premise 2 only states that some women are doctors, not all. Therefore, this conclusion is not guaranteed by the premises.

Option 2: All doctors are entrepreneurs

This statement () claims that the entire group of doctors is contained within the group of entrepreneurs. We know that all women are entrepreneurs () and some women are doctors (). This means the women who are doctors are also entrepreneurs. However, the premises do not provide information about doctors who might not be women. There could be male doctors who are not entrepreneurs. Thus, we cannot conclude that all doctors are entrepreneurs.

Option 3: All entrepreneurs are women

This statement () claims that the entire group of entrepreneurs is contained within the group of women. This is the converse of Premise 1 () and is not necessarily true. Premise 1 allows for entrepreneurs who are not women.

Option 4: Some entrepreneurs are doctors

Let's consider the individuals mentioned in Premise 2: these are people who are both women and doctors. Let's call this group 'X'. So, , and we know is not empty.

From Premise 1, we know that all women are entrepreneurs (). Since the individuals in group X are women, they must also be entrepreneurs.

Therefore, the individuals in group X are:

- Doctors (from Premise 2)
- Women (from Premise 2)
- Entrepreneurs (because they are women, and all women are entrepreneurs, from Premise 1)

This means there exist individuals who are both entrepreneurs and doctors. In set notation, this means . This perfectly matches the conclusion "Some entrepreneurs are doctors".

Final Conclusion

Based on the analysis, the only conclusion that is logically inferred from the statements "All women are entrepreneurs" and "Some women are doctors" is that "Some entrepreneurs are doctors".

Practice this question

Try it yourself before checking the explanation above.

Read the statements:

All women are entrepreneurs.

Some women are doctors

Which of the following conclusions can be logically inferred from the above statements?
A
All women are doctors
B
All doctors are entrepreneurs
C
All entrepreneurs are women
D
Some entrepreneurs are doctors

Share This Question

Related Questions

mediumMCQ

Ravi had ______ younger brother who taught at ______ university. He was widely regarded as ______ honorable man.Select the option with the correct sequence of articles to fill in the blanks.

mediumMCQ

The CEO’s decision to downsize the workforce was considered myopic because it sacrificed long-term stability to accommodate short-term gains.Select the most appropriate option that can replace the word “myopic” without changing the meaning of the sentence.

mediumMCQ

The average marks obtained by a class in an examination were calculated as 30.8 . However, while checking the marks entered, the teacher found that the marks of one student were entered incorrectly as 24 instead of 42 . After correcting the marks, the average becomes 31.4 . How many students does the class have?

mediumMCQ

Consider the relationships among P, Q, R, S, and T:• P is the brother of Q.• S is the daughter of Q.• T is the sister of S.• R is the mother of Q.The following statements are made based on the relationships given above.(1) R is the grandmother of S.(2) P is the uncle of S and T.(3) R has only one son.(4) Q has only one daughter.Which one of the following options is correct?

mediumMCQ

According to the map shown in the figure, which one of the following statements is correct?Note: Assume a standard top-down map layout based on the text descriptions where North (N) is at the top, West (W) is left, East (E) is right, and South (S) is bottom.Locations mapping:Top Row: Chemistry Lab, Physics Lab, LibraryBottom Area: Hostels, Classrooms, Hospital, Canteen ![image](https://pub-7faa453bd1ec4bf0a04cc031c6f058de.r2.dev/images/e763222c-36c4-4b4a-bfe9-e3bb5be17f44.png)

mediumMCQ

“I put the brown paper in my pocket along with the chalks, and possibly other things. I suppose every one must have reflected how primeval and how poetical are the things that one carries in one’s pocket: the pocket-knife, for instance the type of all human tools, the infant of the sword. Once I planned to write a book of poems entirely about the things in my pocket. But I found it would be too long: and the age of the great epics is past.”(From G.K. Chesterton’s “A Piece of Chalk”)Based only on the information provided in the above passage, which one of the following statements is true?

Ready for a Full Test?

Practice with timed mock tests and track your performance across General Aptitude.

Discussion